FOURTH GRADE HISTORY
Part Seven: Steamboats and the Trail of Tears
Steamboats on the Cumberland River in Nashville
As we said before: When Nashville first became a city, people who lived there could send their goods downstream on the Cumberland River to New Orleans on flatboats. (A flatboat basically being a big wooden raft with sides attached to it.) But they couldn’t come back by boat because mechanized water travel didn’t exist yet. It was easier to take a horse or even walk than it was to paddle against the river current.
Then, in the 1790s, the steamboat was invented. In its early years steamboats weren’t too powerful, and many people weren’t sure if they would ever be able to operate on fast-moving rivers such as the Cumberland and Tennessee. Finally, in March 1819 the first steamboat ever arrived in Nashville. It was called the General Jackson.
Steamboats were quite large. Getting them up and down the river could be a challenge. PHOTO: Bill Carey collection
Within a few years most of the trade that had previously been operating on flatboats had shifted to steamboats, and there were dozens of them that ran up and down the Cumberland River. No longer was it necessary to float down the river and come back home by road, which is why the Natchez Trace lost its significance.
The steamboat was a great invention, but its emergence didn't necessarily mean that every city on a river could be reached easily with them. Steamboats are big and wide, and water has to be about three to five feet deep for a steamboat to make it through. Back in those days, before dams were built up and down the Cumberland and Tennessee rivers, there were many places along the river where the water wasn’t deep enough for a steamboat. A few miles northwest of Nashville, for instance, was a place called Harpeth Shoals. This area was so shallow that steamboats would frequently run aground there (in fact, many steamboats would stop just below Harpeth Shoals and let all their cargo and passengers out there).
The Muscle Shoals were such a navigational problem on the Tennessee River that they were clearly depicted on this map, drawn in 1821.
The Tennessee River, meanwhile, was even harder to navigate. Look at the map and find where the Tennessee River passes through Muscle Shoals, Alabama. In the old days, you simply could not take a large boat through this area; the river was too shallow and unpredictable. This is extremely important. What this meant is that cities upstream of Muscle Shoals – Chattanooga and Knoxville, for instance – couldn’t take full advantage of steamboats. In fact, the invention of the steamboat shifted growth from Knoxville to Nashville. It was right about this time (1826) that the legislature shifted the state capital to Nashville for the first time. And this inability to fully take advantage of the steamboat is why, a generation later, people in Knoxville and Chattanooga were more anxious for railroads to come to Tennessee than the people in Nashville.
The Trail of Tears
Some parts of our history are painful to recount. The Trail of Tears is one of those parts.
A timeline of events in Tennessee from 1819 to 1854 IMAGE: Lauren A. Roussel
When
Tennessee first became a state, it only consisted of about one-eighth of the land that it does today. Most of the rest of the land still belonged to the Native American tribes. However, as the years passed, the American government purchased those lands from the Native Americans. The biggest single purchase came in 1817, when
Tennessee acquired its western third via the Chickasaw Purchase.
After that, the only part of
Tennessee still left to Native Americans was the southeast part that was owned by the Cherokees. The Cherokees also still inhabited large parts of western
North Carolina and northwest Georgia.
By this time many Cherokees had adapted white culture. The Cherokees were no longer on the warpath. Many Cherokees had large farms and sold goods at market just like other farmers; while there were Cherokees working as blacksmiths, tailors, and other things. The Cherokees had largely adopted the Christian religion, and some of them had even fought on the American side in the war of 1812 and the Creek War of 1813-14. And, thanks to Sequoyah, the Cherokees now had a written language and their own newspaper.
This Tennessee map from 1821 shows some of the land the Cherokees still possessed at that time.
Nevertheless, Americans still wanted all of the Cherokees’ land – call it greed if you must. Many leaders in and Tennessee felt this way. One of them, Andrew Jackson, was elected president in 1828. Jackson generally hated Native Americans, describing them as “immoral” and “wandering savages” – although he could be kind to them on an individual basis. He had fought against them many times – most notably at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend in present-day Alabama, when he led an army that defeated the Creeks.
The same year Jackson was elected, a Cherokee boy discovered gold in northwest Georgia – right in the middle of the Cherokee land. As soon as this happened, white prospectors (people looking to find gold) poured into the area. Some whites, hoping to run the Cherokees off of their land, began sneaking onto Cherokee country and plundering and burning homes in an attempt to run them off. The Cherokees of northwest Georgia lost the legal battle that followed, and by 1832 members of the tribe were prohibited from engaging in political activity within the state of Georgia, which is why the tribe shifted its capital to Red Clay -- just north of the Tennessee/Georgia state line.
On May 28, 1830, President Jackson signed the Indian Removal Act, requiring all Native Americans to leave their homes and move west of the Mississippi River. Many Cherokees refused to go, and filed a lawsuit against the government to stop this from taking place. That lawsuit went all the way to the U. S. Supreme Court, which ruled that the Cherokees had every right to remain on their land. But Jackson refused to do what the Supreme Court told him to. “[Chief Justice] John Marshall has rendered his decision," Jackson said. “Let him enforce it.”
By the way, Jackson probably should have been removed from office for doing this, because the president is supposed to respect the rulings of the Supreme Court. But no one in Congress had the courage to start such a movement.
An artist's depiction of the Trail of Tears IMAGE: Museum of the Cherokee Indian
By 1838 many Native Americans of various tribes had given up and moved west, while others still refused. But in May of that year the federal government began rounding them up and forcing them to go west, in an event that we now call the Trail of Tears.
Here is how one book describes what happened when American troops showed up to remove the Cherokees:
"Without warning, the troops burst into Cherokee homes, dragged the people outside, and drove them toward staging camps. Anyone moving too slowly was prodded by a soldier’s bayonet. Following almost on the heels of the soldiers came neighboring whites who swept up the Cherokee’s personal possessions just as soon as the soldiers had forced the Indians from their homes. Like pirates, the whites stuffed sacks with pots, pans, silverware, and musical instruments, all looted from Cherokee houses and cabins."
-- from the book The Trail of Tears by R. Conrad Stein
This map shows the routes Native Americans took during the Trail of Tears
After being packed into “staging areas” – generally nothing more than fenced-in areas guarded by soldiers – around 16,000 Cherokees were marched northwest from present-day Chattanooga up through Murfreesboro, Nashville, and Clarksville and into Kentucky, enroute to present-day Oklahoma. The journey took over a year and a half, and it is estimated that one in four of the people who traveled this route died along the way.
Many years later, an old soldier had this to say about what he saw during the removal of the Native Americans. “I fought through the Civil War and I have seen men shot to pieces and slaughtered by thousands, but the Cherokee removal was the cruelest work I ever knew.”
Click here for a remarkable account of how one Cherokee man and his wife escaped during the Trail of Tears and made it back to their homeland.
This display at the Museum of the Cherokee Indian shows a Native American arriving in present-day Oklahoma after the Trail of Tears.
By the way, about a thousand Cherokees who were known as the Oconaluftee Citizen Indians refused to leave and hid in deep ravines, caves and cliffs of the
Great Smoky Mountains
, where it would be almost impossible to round them up. One of them was named Tsali, and he had killed a white soldier for jabbing a bayonet at his wife. Cherokee legend claims that Tsali gave himself up in exchange for an agreement allowing other members of his tribe to stay in the mountains. The people who live at the Cherokee Indian Reservation believe that they are there today because of Tsali.
QUIZ
1. After steamboats were invented, why did Nashville grow faster than Knoxville?
2. (TRUE OR FALSE) The discovery of gold in north Georgia was one of the things that led to the Trail of Tears.
3. (TRUE OR FALSE) The U. S. Supreme court backed President Andrew Jackson’s decision to forcibly remove Native Americans from
Tennessee.
ASSIGNMENT: Go to the library and find a story about the Trail of Tears written by someone who was there when it happened. (This would be known as a first-person account.)
ASSIGNMENT: Go to the library and see if you can track down copies of old, old
Tennessee maps that show how the state’s boundaries changed between 1796 and 1818.
For quiz answers, click here.
Click here to read about the coming of railroads to Tennessee.
|